J.Crew No. 57

Really enjoying this now that the weather is colder! I bought this on major clearance at J. Crew, together with No. 31. Of the two, I think I prefer this one, No 57. It is, as others have said, a warm, golden, whiskey-inflected, vanilla woodsy composition. It has a sweetness to it that I don't find cloying or gourmand. It smells to me the way whiskey should taste if whiskey tasted good (I'm not a whiskey drinker). I don't pick up a lot of the cinnamon, just a touch, which is good because I don't want to smell like one of the ubiquitous cinnamon brooms that haunt supermarkets right now. On me, this last pretty well, at least 5-6 hours although it gets softer and softer. By hour 7, it is mostly gone. Glad I bought it (on sale) when I could!

This is a nice unisex vanilla for 20 bucks. Just don't go into it expecting something more. When I first tried this i was turned off because I was expecting something much darker, heavier, and boozier. There are woods and smoky peaty whiskey notes, but the drydown is all about vanilla. A woodsy, cinnamon-kissed vanilla that is perfectly cozy, unisex, and lasts all day. Nothing essential, but very wearable and pleasing. 7.5/10

Pretty surprised. Got this on clearance for $20 and I was stunned at how good the scent was. I get a woody, boozy, cinnamon. Performance could be better but for the price I cannot complain. If this lasted longer than 4 hours it might be a perfect 10. 9.5/10

I smelled this today and the first thing that hit me was Escada Sentiment which I owned a but over 10 years ago. You really get the cinnamon burst in it followed by hints of sweet vanilla; very solid for $70.

It's amazing in it's simplicity. Ive not smelt anything with these notes that comes off as reserved like this perfume does. I have the roller and it's my the perfect sweet resin vanilla for work.