Sweet Tooth Lemon Pie

Guys, I literally ordered this the day Sabrina announced it. When it came in the mail and I smelt it for the first time, I literally gasped. I honestly think this is the best perfume I have ever smelt in my life. I'm obsessed. I took this on vacation with me the day after I had received it and went through the whole 30ml in 5 days. The 75ml is sold out literally everywhere am I am crushed. When I can finally get my hands on a 75ml, I am going to buy like 5 bottles because I truly have never smelt a perfume that smells this good. I have gotten so many compliments, including I got a compliment when I was in a casino, which is saying a lot because for those of you who have been in a casino, you know it smells only of cigarettes, and someone could smell this delicious scent over the casino. I think I could drink this perfume. My friend who usually stays away from sweet gourmand scents, also is obsessed with it. I could write paragraphs and paragraphs about how good this perfume is but I don't anyone would like to read that lol. Just buy it trust me, but please don't sell it out again because I will cry. Also if you like this scent and have curly or wavy hair, try the brand Cake. You can find their products on Amazon and they are very affordable. Their products share a similar scent to this fragrance and pair wonderfully with it.

I was worried that this would be yet another clean, fresh lemon trying to pass itself off as a gourmand lemony pastry scent - but the rumors are true!!! when I tell you that I have been yearning for a lemon fragrance like this one for YEARS...ever since I began my fragrance collection in 2023. one of the first scents that I quested for was a realistic sugared lemon pie scent. but every suggestion that I took just smelled...wrong. akro bake smells like B.O. on me. super milk smells like sour cheese. xerjoff lira smells like sour lemon candy. I had honestly given up on ever finding the lemon pie perfume of my dreams. but then my girl sabrina hard launched this one and I buy whatever mother releases. like I said, my expectations for this were...not too high. but holy fuck. this fragrance literally smells exactly like a lemon custard pie with a graham cracker crust. finally, my quest is over! I will say that the scent will disintegrate from your skin in probably less than 30 minutes, but if you spray it on your clothes then that shouldn’t be an issue!

A very unique, striking fragrance, so it makes sense it wouldn't be everyone's cup of tea. However, to me it smells fantastic, the fresh, sugary lemon is accompanied superbly by the delicious graham cracker scent, creating a fun, youthful vibe. Yep, it is sweet, but the lemon keeps it balanced and crisp. So far I have only used it in summer weather, mostly opting to spray it on for the less hot days (up to around 30 degrees), but it performed quite well in the heat too, and it didn't get overtly sweet at all. Contrary to some comments, I have found that it lasts quite long on my skin, so I have praise for its longevity as well. The scent stays clean and balanced over the day, and doesn't change into anything unpleasant or suffocating like some sweet scents do. Overall a very impressive, enjoyable and remarkable fragrance, and a new favourite to me!

Where do I even start? It has to be in top 5 sweetest, most edible fragrances I’ve ever had the pleasure to try. It smells EXACTLY like crackers layered with lemon cream. I smell it, and I wanna eat it. Can’t get enough of the sweetness here. It’s not cloying at all, which is a rare advantage in case of fragrances that smell like a dessert at nice café. A huge advantage here is the longevity - it projects subtly, with not much of change in smell over time, and lasts good seven to eight hours without reapplication. Especially if you spray it on pulse areas, you have the longevity guaranteed. This perfume is simply sweet, creamy, delicious and perfect for summertime. I would also recommend getting a body mist, to get a lighter dose of the creamy, candied, café vibe that Lemon Pie serves. As a gourmand fragrance lover, I’m in absolute love.

Oh my goodness the shipping time on this thing was so worth it, I adore this <3<3 I was so expecting it to be way too lemon heavy (I hate lemon scents, I hate lemon pie for that matter) BUT THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. It’s done so perfectly, I’m absolutely blown away. I had zero expectations honestly, but this was an instant winner when i first smelled it, the lemons not too sharp or cleaner like, the graham cracker is way more prevalent and balances the lemon so well... I will say if I spray it too close to my nose it’ll be a bit too lemony but if I keep it on a less concentrated spray its sooo good. Another win from Sabrina, I really should’ve guessed at this point as all her other frags are my most favorite out of all I own hah- But yeah! Delicious, lovely little romanticized lemon pie perfume <3

https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Sabrina-Carpenter/Sweet-Tooth-Lemon-Pie-120032.html?ccid=2819359#focus-zone This person is so very correct! This product is getting review bombed by haters who can't stand to see either women or non-wealthy people happy or are hung up on discourse and hate this perfume simply because it's from Sabrina. (eta: oh look, the very comment after mine is someone whining about her as an artist) For some real comments from someone wearing it right now: this is very much a SPRING fragrance, not a winter like I currently see in the voting (though that's sure not gonna stop me from wearing now), definitely an intimate daytime fragrance, and I can still smell it even though it's been five or so hours since I put it on.

Photorealistic Lemon cookies -- 🍪🍋 I really thought I hated lemon gourmands or any citrusy gourmands until I smelled that one... That's just so good, and honestly that's probably one of her best ones after my favorite of all time Sweet Tooth Eau de Parfum . This opens up with a sweet lemony scent, it's quickly followed by a super gourmand/ crusty cookie note, it's super good and the lemon doesn't smell off putting, it's very sugary and easy to love. it fades into a creamy vanilla - soft meringue and this is where I can agree with the "lemon pie" name. I'm the most fan of the cookie part of this perfume, absolutely SO realistic. Incredible !

I work at bath and body works and this is very reminiscent of iced lemon poundcake.. (or a straight up REAL lemon meringue pie/lemon Girl Scout cookies) so it’s safe to say that I absolutely LOVEEEE IT! I just love this type of scent profile sooo much. So addictive, delicious and nostalgic for me <3.. smells more in line with Lira/Bake (that TRUE photorealistic lemon poundcake scent) as opposed to Devotion, but does still share similarities of course. Not the greatest longevity or projection and the atomizer is notttt good I can’t lie lol it sucks but I loveee the smell! Def one of my fave interpretations of this scent profile

received this as a gift and honestly it’s the best one yet! wore it out all day today and i just felt so soft and sweet like a buttery lemon cookie. my main gripe with her fragrances was that they’re tended to lean a bit synthetic on the nose. however this one is so soft and easy on my nose and i immediately smelled the cream and lemony notes! it settles into a more soft sweet biscuit like scent with the lemon disappearing hours into the dry down.

This might eventually take the original Sweet Tooth’s place as my favorite Sabrina perfume! Smells like a delicious lemon pie with the graham cracker, meringue top, and all. Both lemon notes in this are soft and feathery light, surrounded by fuzzy and creamy sweetness. I can’t wait to see how this does during spring and summer for me! This is what I wish Victoria by Lattafa was. I hope she keeps this around, especially after her last fragrance 😅

I'm so happy I finally got my hands on it!! This is way better than I expected it to be, it really smells like a freshly baked lemon vanilla cake! I have never come across a perfume this good, I would recommend it to anyone who wants a sweet, unique, glamourous feeling perfume. It's the best she has come out with so far, then Caramel is after it and the original. I have the espresso but I would not repurchase and I never got her cherry one.

Ok, this opens very creamy--a super creamy lemon, slightly lactonic. Then it morphs into lemon sugar wafer cookies, which is lovely as well. The mid-drydown is more of a tart lemon and is slightly less foody on me but it once again morphs into a tart lemon/graham crackery creamy lemon pie. Very delicious, cute bottle, super affordable. Longevity and sillage are minimal, sadly. But as cheap as this is, I don't mind. Worth it!

I really like this perfume! It’s warm and comforting and smells like a lemon pie without being overpowering. I don’t generally love perfumes that smell like food, but this one is beautiful and very wearable. It does not last long at all, and people around you probably won’t be able to smell it unless you just put it on and oversprayed, but I enjoy it as an everyday around the house and out running errands type of scent.

Bought it, because it smells VERY similar to "Unknown Pleasures" by Kerosene for a fracture of the price. (Main difference in my opinion is, that Unknown Pleasures smells more like a lemon-vanilla CAKE while Lemon Pie is more biscuit/cookie-like. And also that you have to re-apply the latter every 2h or so. But I am in fact very ok with that, if that means I am only paying 28€ for a perfume.)

I'm so happy I got it, when I first smelled it I swear I imidiatly fell in love, I could honestly marry the thing lol. Deffinetly smells like some sort of lemon cake to me though the boyfriend said it smelled like white chocolate. If you like the other ones in the series I definitely think you'd like this one, I'm so happy to have a lemony smell that isn't super fresh and clean finally.

It smells just like Lemon Tart! Very realistic. I love it. At first it smells like Lemon peel with sugar and vanilla, then it dries down to bisquits with butter and vanilla sugar and little bit of lemon peel. The longevity of citrus smell is short, pretty quickly it becomes a light vanilla bakery scent. Even though it's not strong, it makes me happy. Lovely 10/10

I LOVE this scent, it is a photorealistic lemon pie, just EXACTLY like you’d picture based on the name. It’s kinda faint so it takes a few extra sprays but it’s bright and fun and dries a little sweeter than it sprays. It’s perfect for spring or day time and feels very sunny and youthful. It’s hard to pick a favorite in this line but I do love this one.

This perfume smells far more “baked good” than citrus to me, but I quite like it! The graham cracker notes really shine through; it’s truely giving pie. Probably not for everyone, but if you like sweeter smelling perfumes this is a good one. I’m probably going to end up layering this with something more citrus forward to get the perfect combo for me.

i immediately got hit with the lemon and my eyes lit up but when it dried down all i could smell was vanilla and graham crackers :/ wish there were some citrus dry notes too. also, feel like it's too gourmand to be a "summer perfume". it would be good for the months where the weather is changing between hot and cold, like march and september.

Very distinctly smells like lemon pie creme and graham crackers. One of the best gourmands that I own. Smells like an actual dessert and not the "perfume version" of what the scent is supposed to be, if you know what I mean. Bought a travel size on a whim from Ulta, will definitely be going back for a full size bottle when I get the chance.

I truly love this scent. It smells like flaky crust and powdery lemons, which dries down quickly so it’s more of a light perfume. It’s very hard to make a lemon scented perfume that doesn’t smell like cleaner so I commend this for not smelling like that at all. It doesn’t have very good longevity though so I would recommend layering it.

the most photo-realistic lemon pie fragrance EVER! the notes of graham cracker really shine through and complement the decadent lemon meringue cream pie. i am so in love with this fragrance, the only letdown is it doesn't last whatsoever. one spray and it's gone in an hour... 3 it is such an edible and sweet pick-me-up though!

This IMO is very different from Devotion. This one is not boozy and is way more gourmand. Smells exactly like a lemon cream pie or lemon bars 🍋💛. I find the longevity to be on par with the other sweet tooths. I’m not sure why but this also reminds me of Easter lol. If you like gourmands you will definitely like this one!

This might be her best one yet! Very close to topping the original! I loooove this scent and I usually dont care for citrus scents. This can be paired with Devotion or Lolita Land! I also layer it with Bath & Body Works Milk Bar Cereal Milk and it smells like fruit loops! Im so glad my fiancée bought this for me!

I don't like any of the flankers, but I loooove this one 🥰✨🍋🍦 It's sweet, lemon meringue, fluffy, buttery, airy, yummy 🤤😋 Not boozy at all. Gourmand for sure! It's so fun and uplifting. Perfect for Easter time and if you're around kids, they'll love it! 🐇🐣🤍💛💞💞💞 It's such a shame it lasts for a maximum of 1h... 🥲

Hear me out: this is Chocolate Greedy by Montale with lots of lemon. That said, I think this is the best yet from SC. It's lemon cheesecake in a bottle. Performance is pretty weak, but for the price I can't really complain. All my daughters love it which is a very rare occurrence. They never agree on anything.

I’ve never smelled a Sabrina Carpenter Fragrance before, this one smells amazing though. Very warm, toasty meringue scented, the graham cracker note is noticeable and delicious. Thankfully not an overpowering lemon cleaner scent but more of a baked good scent. Pretty good sillage while not being overbearing.

Çook lezzetli kokuyor, müthiş 🤤. Limonlu cheesecake kokusu tam olarak bu işte. Limon kabuğu rendelenmiş anne keki gibi de kokuyor. Notalarında olmasa da bence birazcık karamel kokusu da geliyor, ama böyle acı/kavruk karamel değil sütlü sütlü triliçe karameli; o kadar güzel ki 🥹💕

Got this in a little purse spray and I love love love it! It really smells like pie, graham cracker and all. Sweet but not overwhelming. Longevity isn’t great, if I wear this out to work it’ll fade within the hour but since I’m used to body mists I can’t complain about that xD

I already wrote a review but I had to come back to tell you that it is sooo good! I actually want to eat it. 😂 I should have gone for the bigger bottle. And this is coming from someone who doesn't like fruity scents at all! Get it get it get it! Is it that sweet? I guess so 😌

Quite vanillary and the lemon is very refreshing and pleasant. It smells like lemon meringue pie but is playful and sweet. It's not overpowering and you can layer it. It stays true and the scent doesn't vary much as it wears off. It's classy and subtle. Five stars.

i am OBSESSED with this lemon pie, it smells exactly like a delicious lemon meringue pie. the bottle is super cute and is so nice to display with my other sabrina perfumes. however, this fragrance disappears in less than 30 minutes and has little to no sillage.

This fragrance from the sweet tooth line is my favorite, it is a very simple fragrance but it is SO good if you love lemon perfumes. It smells like a sweet lemon pie. Lemon can sometimes pull a little bit like a cleaning spray but this doesnt do that at all.

i LOVE this one. its the most addicting out of the bunch and it feels like a bunch of freshly baked vanilla scented lemon muffins. straight out of the bakery, it feels very gourmand to me. 10/10, would buy again if i could

All Sabrina Carpenter perfumes are dull and unpleasant for me, but this one is so tasty. Very nostalgic for some reason and gives me comfort. Finally found it in stock at the drugstore, people buy it like crazy (valid).

absolutely beautiful. it smells like a airy, powdery lemon and dries down to a sweet flaky crust. perfect for summer, not cloying like most gourmands and truly a staple if you want to smell edible all year around :)

This is really nice, I think it's a matter of taste because the graham cracker note is really in your face but as a fan of that smell I really liked it. It fades quickly but for the price that's fine in my opinion.

This fragrance is fantastic if I want to wear something light and sweet it’s such a cozy smell and last quite some time on my skin will definitely be a repurchase as I enjoy wearing it and the scent a lot

This perfume smells so good! Smells like very edible lemon cake. The graham cracker note is very much present. As someone who doesn't usually go for lemon or citrus scents, this is really good. 🍋🥧

much more realistic. better than the og and flankers! pairs well with my chelsea morning. not super long lasting vis a vie the og. but way better on the nose. not too citrusy but perfectly cakey.

love this! Sweet, but not cloying, and so realistic. I mostly get the crust and the cream, and the lemon isn't too tart. I wore it to work yesterday and could smell it all day. Made me happy!

That’s just heavenly. I got espresso and cherry already and i dismissed this one. I though its lemon and I don’t like lemonish perfumes. I tried it in a store later. Loved it instantly.

absolute gem. i always wanted such a scent and i got the body mist version bcuz my local drugstore was sold out of it :/ but it still smells really good! despite the poor longevity...

It’s more gourmand and mouth watering than Lira. You wanna smell like lemon pie this is lemon pie. Or lemon cookies. 3D level gourmand. But It lasts as long as those desserts too...

This perfume is literally lemon pie I love all Sabrina perfumes and this one is definitely in my top 3 I look forward to new ones in the future, I hope there will be more of them.

oh my gosh this literally smells edible and delectable. straight up sweet lemon graham cracker i can taste it. i've never leaned towards citrus fragrances but this is YUMMY

What actual [REDACTED]s just typed the word "sweet" into the "reminds me of" section and clicked whatever they saw? How does it feel to contribute nothing to society

It's perfect, if it was bottled with a niche brand it could easily charge usd200. Long lasting on my skin. The best one from the brand.

YUMMM i love this one and the cherry one from her. smells nearly identical to iced lemon pound cake from bath and body works

It smells SOOOOO good. This perfume is what I've been looking for with Lemon perfumes. I smell like a lemon cake 😩🩷🩷🩷