Cozy Fireside S'more

This smells a LOT like Bath and Body Work's "Vanilla Bean" (not to be confused with the far more popular, but less awesome Vanilla Bean Noel) which has long been discontinued. However, this isn't an exact dupe and it's worth having both if you're into inexpensive, but amazing gourmond thrills! I'm so happy I tried this, it actually was love at first sniff. As always, things like this aren't overly complicated, they're understandable, and they're fairly linear. However, it satisfies that gourmond itch perfectly, and this one doesn't smell overly artificial or tacky...it's nice. It has a warm chocolatey tone predominantly, but there's quite a heavy dash of vanilla too. It's almost verging on cakey, but it doesn't smell decidedly like graham crackers. That's alright. This is fantastic, and although I don't need another fragrance mist, it was worth far more than the $4 I paid. I'd spend close to $50 (if I had it available for a treat) on something that smelled like this. 🍫 🍂

I have both the og formulation (2020) and the current one, and they smell similar but with different focuses. The 2020 version focuses more on the smokey sandalwood, making it more unisex. It lasts for 6-8 hours and has a decent projection, about arms length. The current version is more watered down, with an emphasis on marshmallow and chocolate. To me this one registers more feminine, and the smokey sandalwood is still there, just in the background. It performs more like a skin scent, and it lasts 4-5 hours on me. Both overall smell like a recreation of By the Fireplace from someone who has never smelled it in their life, and is going by descriptions. Which is not bad, just don’t expect this to smell identical to BtF.

so lovely but very light! at first, i couldn't smell anything but this actually got stronger on me over time and lasted amazingly, which was a pleasant surprise. it opens with a smokiness like by the fireplace, then smells like creamy sandalwood with a sweet and powdery quality from the marshmallow and a little chocolatey sweetness that becomes more apparent when warmed, without being excessively gourmand or cloying. even my mum, who hates perfume, enjoyed this fragrance. i wish they made this part of their permanent line though! i had to wait around 6 months before i was able to purchase mine :(

Gorgeous soft Smokey vanilla scent. I don’t get chocolate, and the woodiness is not too much either. I never got to try bonfire bash, so I’m guessing if they re released it, if it smells like this I’d absolutely hoard it. Cozy fireside smore is very light, unfortunately. It’s a my skin but better scent surely. it’s great for layering to add depth to your fragrance, or just wear on its on if you’re going for something soft. The fragrance and packaging are a 10/10 love for me. But the projection isn’t strong enough for me to love this like I want to.

for $5 this mist is an absolute great bang for your buck if you’re a vanilla/gourmand person like i am! the scent brings me back to childhood parties/hangouts at my family friends’ houses and sitting around their firepit telling scary stories with my friends to scare the younger kids—pure sweet nostalgia. i especially recommend layering this with vanilla skin by phlur, coffee break by maison margiela, eilish by billie eilish, or dulce by rosie-jane(my fav combination of the four is vanilla skin though).

This is divine. I appreciate when Fragrantica adds bodycology into their database. I don’t own Bonfire Bash nor have I smelled it, but if this is similar I don’t think I need to. This is powdery milk chocolate, sandalwood, and toasted marshmallow. Gourmand but not in a cheesy way. I have the body cream and the spray and together they will last hours and hours. Warm, cozy, divine. Also great for layering. A steal. I need to quit wasting my $ on BBW if the rest of this line is as good!

To my nose this is the perfect dupe for the ORIGINAL Bonfire Bash that came out years ago. The new BB smells kinda weird like they added a nasty, more synthetic smoke smell, whereas it used to smell like natural wood and a deep, boozy vanilla. It was amazing. This smells like the original for me. Surprisingly these body sprays are pretty strong and last a good while for me, so they're absolutely worth it. I try to stock up on the ones I really like since they're so cheap.

I LOVEEE this body spray you guys, I got it about two months ago and I swear I have used it every day along with any of my vanilla-based perfumes, and even my caramel-based perfumes😭😭 it literally smells like what it’s called...like a cozy fire side s’more and my boyfriend can attest to that haha. I don’t know how I haven’t come across this body mist sooner and I got it at Walmart for only five dollars so I would definitely recommend PLUS it is the perfect fall scent too.

Another find of mine that took multiple years ! (3 to be exact). The first sprays are quite disappointing and watery down? Smells like alcohol with a LOT of smokyness. After few seconds it turns into a smoky - woody marshmallow (very light note) with an (barely existing) chocolate note. Now, the dry down?? AMAZING. So fluffy, marshmallowy with a delicious note of chocolate. It's becoming even quite strong after few minutes.

just amazing!! i am more of a super sugary sweet gourmand person but i still love this. to me, it's a bit more woody compared to super sweet, but the creamy marshmallow and chocolate add in the sweetness that i love as a gourmand person. for some reason on me, it dries down a little soapy?? but i still rly like this! the body wash is a lot more sweet marshmallow forward!

This smells wonderful. Amber, woody, sweet. I layer it with my Al Rehab Love Apple for a cozy holiday scent. Unfortunately, this spray doesn’t last long at all on me. It diminishes in about 30 minutes. Sometimes it lingers on clothes though. It reminds me very much of Clinique’s My Happy— Cookies & Kisses. Very similar. Lasts a little longer too. Would be nice to layer.

this is the fragrance that got me hooked on sandalwood. there's no funny business, it smells exactly like sandalwood and s'mores. perfect scent for bedtime. you have to spray a lot of it though, and for a crazy cheap perfume it does have an impressive longevity. last time i got hooked to a bodycology scent, they discontinued it. so i'm using this sparingly.

It smells like slightly toasted marshmallows and sandalwood with the tiniest bit of chocolate, i love it!!! its very cozy, gourmandy, pleasant, and its great for layering. This lasts about 1-2 hrs on my skin but up to 4-6 hrs on my clothes (i'm an oversprayer). You cant beat the price and its a really good scent for winter.

I love how it smells exactly like chocolate melted on a marshmallow. I will say though I am disappointed that the newer bottles don't smell as strong as it used to when it was a limited sent, Its definitely watered down now but that smores sent is still the same it just wont last as long as it used to.

these are back in stock now for fall at Walmart in the new b&bw-esque packaging. don't overpay on ebay like I almost did. smells so nice for the $5 price, but would not succumb to the $15-20 price tag elsewhere. less chocolatey than cocoa butter lotion but with soft marshmallow, hnggg it's so good!!

Great scent especially for the value, this one is my favorite from Bodycology, I have both old and new package and the newest one is lighter than the previous one but nevertheless pretty good. Overall is a crowd pleasing, slightly smoky but not overpowering like By the fireplace. Good for layering.

Smells like chocolate chip cookie dough 🍪 I love layering this with other perfumes to give a vanilla chocolate note! It lasts a pretty good while on clothing for being a body mist in my opinion. I love the Bodycology brand. My other favorite is strawberry cheesecake

This one reminds me of abuelita hot chocolate and melted marshmallows, it smells sweet and fully edible. 5 bucks isn’t it? The lasting power is unsurprising for a body spray but it’s so delicious that I wish it were a bit stronger.

This is a 100% dupe for Maison Margiela By the Fireplace. I picked it up at Walmart clearance section for $3.95. So mad because I just bought a bottle of the MMBTFP a couple weeks ago. I could have saved so much.

This is one of my favorite scents of all time, the sandalwood is not overpowering in any sense and this smells really feminine. I wish I could find a clone or reup but I think it’s only seasonal :/