A*Men Pure Malt Creation

Immediately hit with a mild booziness that reminds me of a premium Manhattan -- whiskey, sweet fruits and spices. In the opening the booziness is accompanies by bright sweet citrus with no sharpness. The citrus pulls back quickly, and the familiar coffee-cedar-patchouli-musk of the original A*men becomes evident as the base, but the "Manhattan" smell still sits out front. As the scent develops over the first hour the cedar adds its usual menthol edge and I am met with a rotating set of smells familiar to those who have nosed whiskey including the smokiness of peat, the hay-like, grain smell of barley, the woods of the barrel, and the spiciness that reminds me of cinnamon or clove, yet not quite either. All the while, the A*men DNA still sits underneath. In the end, you still have a wonderfully gently sweet, slightly smoky, slightly boozy, amber, patchouli, woody smell that I think is exactly what the name promises: A*men + Scottish whiskey. I have the 2013 version, and with obvious exceptions, I don't get into the reformulation thing. But the performance I get is pretty decent. Strong fairly boozy projection for the first hour, moderate projection that is more sweet than boozy for the next several hours, and then a skin scent after around 6 hours, but if I get moving it activates and projects harder. I wear this in 70 degrees or less, which where I live means end of fall through beginning of spring, and usually as an evening scent. Newer boozy smells are boozier, sweet gourmand fragrances are sweeter, and there is more frequently an emphasis on realistic expressions of food and drink. While I certainly enjoy those, I think they also show how balanced and ahead of it all the Mugler A*men line was, and for many, Pure Malt is the best of this line. I love sweet amber woody smells and there is nothing about this fragrance I dislike. I quit buying fragrances in 2008 until recently. Completely missed this gem when it was a "thing" but managed to get this for a very reasonable price and would pull the trigger again at a bottle $1 per ml or less. $250+ a bottle, though? Uh, no thanks. Wish Xerjoff would make an inspired by, like Naxos is to Pure Havane. That would be worth $250... Sooooo... What about Star Man Nebula? Oh, it's pretty good. I bought my bottle 9 months ago, sprayed, then let it sit to mature. The opening is still a different experience for me than Pure Malt, especially back-to-back on the same day. Way more citrus, patchouli and musk in the first couple of minutes and I think at that point, this isn't Pure Malt. But then a few minutes later you start getting that A*men-y feel and then it slowly gets closer and closer to the original. In the first 15 minutes, the closer my nose gets to my skin, the more obvious this is a clone. But even at arm's length, it's really, really close. After that, it smells like you are wearing Pure Malt. A little less booze, but even the gradual development of the cedar and A*men base works the same. So is it worth under $30? Absolutely! Shorter performance, so reapply after 3-4 hours if needed, and you're good. Is it a complete replacement for Pure Malt? If Pure Malt was $100 I'd say stick to the original, but it's not, so buy the clone and get a small decant of the original if you want to compare for yourself.

Have to say I agree with @merekkalinowski very little difference between this an the original. The sales assistant (a very pleasant French lady) was so eager to tell me the story about the whiskey casks and how exclusive this juice was, which was nice actually as most I talk to don't have a clue about fragrances or show any real enthusiasm. I have to look at the process with some scepticism because as a man of science I believe it's pure chemistry and I'm not sure how much perfume can be infused with character in this manner. As a romantic I would love these processes to be possible (oak barrel aging, smoking etc...) because it makes the artistry of perfumery even more magical but I think in this case it maybe a bit of a gimmick. That being Said...trying them side by side as I am at the moment, I get a slight(and I do mean very slight) difference between them. It's not enough really for me to warrant any change from my position on the original A*Men, it's a wonderful complex, oriental, spicy fragrance. I'm glad the whiskey, maltiness is not maximised because I was always reluctant to try because of this but it's subtle...very subtle! If you're somebody who really picks up on the difference between these and love it then good for you because this is a great smelling fragrance and it's £20 cheaper than the original so I'd chose this version even if just from a financial point of view.

Well this one caught me by surprise, especcially after I ordered a bottle of the original from ebay and saw that this one would be released this year. I actually couldn't wait to try this one, and when I did my nose told me instantly: "It is the same one". I am sure lots of people can say that it is the same one as 2009. I can smell some differences. The fruity notes are there as in the original, as is the malt and peat. But after a few hours, it turn into a coffee blend with caramel and chocolate, and it is here where the fusion with A*Men (Original-1996)shows up. In the original Pure Malt, I could smell the caramel and the chocolate in it, but this one its smells different, it smells stronger maybe because of the vanilla. Either way, it's good to bring back a classic if you say that this is the same one, or not, this is a great fragrance and my new addiction. Perfect for the winter cold days and nights. The bottle is simply one of the best ones I ever seen, the gold mirroed star is a great feature to the bottle. If "re-releasing" old fragrances as new fragrances is going to be a trend for Thierry Mugler (remember Pure Energy) I don't oppose. I would really like to see a Pure Havane Spirit or a Pure Coffee Blend of even a Gourmet of Fragrances (Pure Chilli). Let's see if he can surprise us next year Fragrance: 9/10 Bottle: 9/10 Longevity: 9/10 Sillage: 8/10 AWESOME!:)

after getting my pure malt creation, there is a difference to me in the opening, a sweeter version perhaps? still has the dna of the original. trying it on the top of my wrist and the original on the other. The original is still a remarkable fragrance and creation is so very close to me. It does seem to have a little better longevity but not overwhelmingly so. Better projection at first. I really believe those who have pure malt and love it like I do, I say don't think there is any reason to dump your bottle for this one. I still have half of my original left and now have this. I have not tried it in the office yet. I think I need some more time with it to really define if there are distinct differences or do I want there to be?.. Overall it is a great fragrance bearing the same fragrant beauty as the USA version I have with perhaps a sweeter overall aroma. overtime I may notice something more that will distinguish this to a solid conclusion but for now I will just give it a thumbs up, rating it as if I had never smelled my version (whatever year it is? I can't recall)before. Don't lose sleep over this, both are winners, I would be stoked with either. I am going to play with blending them.. see what this combination smells like.

Now this is what is truly meant when people talk about gourmand fragrances. Pure Malt Creation is not just a whisky imbued fragrance, it is one which carries caramelized fruit, milky vanilla, honey and coffee, all served on a sandalwood table strewn with various leaves. When I first breathed it in (one does not lightly sniff this, impulsively you will find yourself engulfing it in), my mind shuddered. It seemed like the epitome of a rich, complex, yet entirely modern fragrance - and one which does not get too 'fussy' or perfumey. It has tremendous richness and depth - possibly more than the original - and definitely does suggest high quality and good materials. Pure Malt Creation is long-lasting with enough development to keep interest and enough projection (but certainly not too much). After four or five hours it will sit closer the skin, but in warmer room environments it will give nice projection even after that time. Personally, I wore this in the evenings on a ski-holiday at Christmas in Mayerhofen and it was just perfect. (Perfectly complemented the Burberry London I was wearing during the day.) Highly recommended try - especially as a Winter evening fragrance.

Dear Bill, Unfortunately we will not be bringing the Amen Pure Malt creation in the United States. Celestially yours, Irene Customer Experience Lead Thierry Mugler USA P:877-843-7968 ________________________________________ when I inquired with mugler stores usa about this fragrance, this was the reply I received..as I was asking why it was not included in the creation group of fragrances.. all I told them was look out ebay. it is shame they do this.. I did tell them I have the original puremalt which I indeed purchased 2 bottles of it when it was re released.. disappointing that this is the style, I did ask why ? but so far no explanation.. I saw here that someone purchased this fragrance thru mugler stores usa? the celestially yours was interesting.. I felt like saying it is a perfume or cologne , it is not some drug curing cancer. I love being fragrance enthusiast. I view it like art .. a perfumers creation,i especially see that on the niche side of things, as they take chances, they are creating their art..the production side comes later.. two thumbs down on mugler but probably would be a thumbs up on the fragrance.. just thought I would share.

When I first tried Pure Malt I really didn't see what the big deal was about and was bitterly disappointed, so much so that I didn't touch it for a week with no real intention to again. Before going out one day I was in a rush and grabbed the closest fragrance I could find and thus sprayed this. Suddenly this fragrance which I really wasn't keen on hit me and I fell in love with it. Maybe it was because I'm fairly new to fragrance collecting and my nose had never smelled anything so bold as a Pure Malt before and didn't know what to think, but it clearly didn't need more than a 2nd chance to appreciate it. From my personal experience I would be weary of when to wear this, as if someone who's into fragrances like me wasn't sure what to make of it at first, I'd be surprised if your average Joe would appreciate it like so many of us do. One thing I couldn't see anyone disliking though is the incredible dry down, which is on par with the perfect DHI for me. I still just about prefer Pure Havanne over this for overall smell alone but for projection and longevity it wins hands down against its brother. 10/10.

I bought this frag during the summer months. I waited to give my review until the fall when most change from spring/summer fragrance. I ♥ the opening aroma of a sweet boozy vib. I'm able to pick up caramel adding to the warm sweet scent. As it dries back I can pick up a fruity/spicy scent...I can barely pick up a cool mint/lavender tone without spoiling the complex aroma. I TOTALLY agree this frag is definitely better than A*Men. longevity and Silage are very high lasting well past 8hrs..excellent! Finally opinion, This was a blind purchase hoping that it wouldn't be as sweet overall. The boozy note of whisky and carmel is a weird combination that you would think spells disaster. Instead this fragrance has a unique blend of different notes coming together beautifully making it ABSOLUTELY STUPENDOUS! One last comment...where's the milk...lol. Rating this fragrance is easily 9/10..perfect during the fall and winter months!!! I would recommend it for those who enjoy Thierry Mugler's fragrance's.

awesome,awesome,awesome.one of the best perfume i have ever buy in my life along 1million(when it released not now) with the very good price.this perfume prove me another time that high price is not mean beter thing.i always want to have boozy and delicious scent that make me and people around crazy and yes this one absolutely do that. the note is whiskey,caramel,honey with the hit of patchuli. last and stuff is adequate.welcome to my best forever 10/10 این عطر برای من از هر لحاظ بی نظیره. نزدیک به 4 ساله که دنبالشم تست کنم ولی متاسفانه پیدا نمی کردم تا آخر سر تو میلاد نور پیدا کردم و تست کردم. وایییییی. همونی که همیشه دنبالش بودم. انگار که یک مرد تا خرخره مشروب خورده باشه و عطره ای من قدیمی رو زده باشه و از بغلتون بگذره و شما ترکیبی از بوی مشروب و عطر ای من قدیمی رو حس کنید. ماندگاری وپخش بو به اندازه کافی هست . از خریده این عطر بسیار خوشحالم و می تونم بگم در کنار عطره وان میلیون که برای اولین بار خریدم حدود 7 سال پیش نه حالا که دیگه جواد شده ٰ یکی از بهترین خریدهای عطرم تو زندگیم بود .

This is a phenomenal fragrance. I bought this blind from a store that was offering limited amount of preorders and was not disappointed. I am so glad I got my hand on this. Pure Malt makes most of the other fragrances out there seem boring in comparison. Easily the best cologne I have owned yet. It smells amazingly sophisticated but also primal (in a good way). A sweet fragrance that is refreshing and warming at the same time. Beautifully crafted by Thierry Mugler! Pure Malt 2013 reminds me of an overcast afternoon in the late Canadian falls when the frost has finally started to become a regularity and the greeneries have all turned into heterogeneous mixtures of yellow and red. It really is the perfect scent for fall but definitely great for other seasons as well (including summer! I don't find it very overpowering as long as you don't go over 2 sprays). Blindbuy? Go for it! Especially if you're a fan of sweet fragrances. Longevity: 9.5/10 Projection: 7.5/10 Smell: 10/10

A*Men Pure Malt Creation is a perfect example of a fragrance where so many things could've gone wrong. Could've been too sweet, or spicy, or boozy or too fruity. But this juice is a masterclass in blending ingredients. Some ingredients obviously shine above others but the end-product really smells like each ingredient belonged there. The whisky note that comes through is not the dirty, peaty smell - it's the sophisticated, refined smell of really expensive single malts. It's not hard to fall in love with this juice. Even if you are not impressed at the first sniff, you'll find yourself sniffing your wrist again and again. It can be a little cloying, so spray with caution. Both, the longevity and the sillage are strong. An excellent fragrance for dates and while clubbing, this will not let you down. A complete winner! Overall: 4.8 5 Nose-gasm 4 Awsome sauce! 3 Good but not exciting enough 2 Meh! 1 Hell to the no!

Elaborating of the topic of perfume is like reckoning of magic. Even if someone does not believe in magic, she or he is carrying a sense of fear towards it. Perfumes are most of the time relating to human souls in just about the same manner. A perfume,liked or dislike, touches us from the inside of our beings. A perfume makes you feel something, be it good or bad. Perfumes are designed to affect your internal sense of mood; they are made to alter or even create your mood and sense of momentary being for certain time... From this perspective, perfumers are giant mood creators; or even souls' 'players'... So, should we talk about perfumes superficially anymore. For instance, if a perfume touches your inside creatively, remember not only the notes, but also the soul who designed it to delight you from innermost.

Okay so this is day two of straight up comparison and contrary to what I have said below there's a definite...definite difference between these two. Absolutely no doubt about it pure malt creation is smoother and sweeter. To be more accurate actually it removes the slightly unpleasant, tinge A*Men has (which makes it sort of interesting actually) and without that barrier you can access the sweetness more easily. Why I never??? The barrel thing actually works!!! It is actually malty, as you spray it right out if the bottle there's a malty, whiskey note that I never really got yesterday. Strikingly similar but honestly I prefer this to the original for sure...what a difference a day makes! I hope they've not sold out.

A Men Pure Malt Creation is just yummy! A wonderfully blended concoction of Caramel,honey, malt, vanilla, creamy milk notes and candied fruits. I smelled the original Pure Malt a few years ago and while I dont have a sample at hand for a side by side test, they are quite similar to my nose if not identical. Monstrous projection for the first couple of hours ( My Dad who was sitting 8 feet away smelled it when I walked into the room) and then settles down for the next 6+ hours of it's life span. Winter and cooler weather frag mostly and a Great frag for a night out or a date as this smells so delicious, you just might end up being dessert if you play your cards right! A really nice gourmand. 9/10

i don't know what it is, but this stuff is wild. amazing. classy. boozy. just awesome. love the the smoky, fruit tinged boozy opening. havn't smelt the 'original' PM but what i've read its the same.. i spray 2 on the chest 1 on the wrist 2 on the neck and one on the shirt. lasts pretty well, 5-7 hours at least. then i loose the scent/goes to a skin scent imo... but like the original A*men, people can smell it well after i loose the scent. i put this up with Dior homme Intense & YSL la nuit del homme, as being one of the all time best scents to wear out. i also think you can pull this off in the summer as well, if you go easier on the sprays

Have to agree with Terry Lennox posting...this 2013 version just doesn't seem to have much longevity on me...have sprayed numerous throughout the day and always seems to fade to a whisper within a few hours...the Pure Leather on the other hand, seems to last 6= hours on me and the sillage is quite heavy also...just ordered Pure Havane and hope that has better longevity on me...having said this, I do like the Pure Malt 2013 notes...just wish it had better longevity and sillage...Really LOVE the Mugler line-up and hope and pray the they relaunch a Pure Coffee in the near future...how about a Pure Mocha Extreme (with a hint of licorice)?

This is a much more refined version of the original Pure Malt. Instead of an empty beer bottle drydown, you get here sweet fruity-vanilla alcoholic vibe which is much safer and more wearable than the original one. I've always felt that the original Pure Malt was more aggressive, therefore more suitable in winter, but Creation is more polished, cosy and feels fine in autumn as well. This is more Glenfiddich whiskey, whereas Pure Malt is Chivas Regal. Overall there's something mesmerizing about the scent and when get wafts of it, I feel very content. Hands down best A*Men flanker, up there with Pure Havane. Love it!

Okay not a final review but first impressions from top to buttom a total love for me although it has some similarities with the vintage pure malt i find this one a lot sweeter. Creation is a lot close to the original A AMEN and the vintage is its own identity. I dont find creation as boozy as the vintage but definitely more gormandish this is by far the perfect interpretation of the original A MEN in my opinion without the harsh tar note definitely a winner on 1 spray last about 8 hours on me with decent projection a winner again from this line I LOVE IT and by the way a female can pull this off.

Just got this but I don't think I'm going to keep it. The opening is WAY too sweet. I love sweet smells usually but this one is way over the top for me. Its very fruity and synthetic on top, kind of like those liqueur filled chocolates with cherry filling. really really sweet. After an hour or two however it becomes much more subdued. Creamy and caramel, some coffee and of course the whiskey. But I just cant get past the opening, it kills me every time. Silage and longevity are absolutely amazing though. 24 hours on my skin, even after i shower i can still smell it there. Beast!

It has a very fruity and boozy opening but after 1 hour... It becomes a very masculine and sexy scent Everyone that smell this on you will come back to smell you again for sure I recommend this to everyone that is new to fragrance game The price is very good for this fragrance And I suggest you to wear darker colored clothes wearing this fragrance Something like leather jacket with a dark jeans and black boots This scent pictures a strong man for me someone that is matured enough but got his wild side too I will buy another bottle of this for sure It is 9/10 for me