Ice(d)-

All three share an extremely similar mint-driven opening (similar to You or Someone Like You, which was made by the same perfumer). So similar that I couldn’t distinguish them in a blind strip test. Drying on skin, however, the differences became more obvious. I find all of them unisex. Iced (-) The greenest, softest, least sweet, and driest of the trio. The mango feels underripe. Cool mint and seaside shrubs give it a blended pale green vibe. I smell similarities with Prin Parfums’ Salted Green Mango. Like a fresh summer drink has been dehydrated before being put in the freezer. If all three of them are smoothies then this is the one with spinach. 8.2/10 Iced Truly feels like the middle ground, but in that context it almost makes it the least memorable of the three. (-) is paler and greener while (+) is more tropical. But on its own, I can see how this might be the most balanced. I think the impression of mint stays the longest in this one by a hair. 8.2/10 Iced (+) It is suitably the boldest profile. As it dries down from the minty green ivy opening, the biggest mango takes over. The added tonka and amber don’t bury the fruit; they simply make it feel riper and sweeter. Richer and more tropical than the others, with an almost fruit-liquer boozy quality imo. It occasionally reminded me of Sapna by Sasva. 8.2/10

I actually quite like this one but it feels a bit redundant in my collection. The cooling mint/mango fades pretty quick compared to the expression version, and what’s left is a slightly fruity, slightly musky, waxy green scent in between Byredo’s La Tulipe and ELDO You or Someone Like You. I didn’t get any seaweed or seawater. I think Ice(d) expressive is a bit more unique, this one is pretty but if you have one or the other of the ones I listed I don’t think it’s necessary.

The opening is nice. Super fresh, fruity aquatic. About 10 minutes in, its a skin scent. But, like the other Ice(d) variants, hints of it wafts in the air. In this one, it's faint. The seaweed takes away from any sweetness of the mango, making it more of a bitter mango. Its smoothed out by sandalwood. Smells nice, but that's only when/if you can smell it.

No thank you. I thought given that I LOVE musk that this would be the one for me but I’ll be honest after a nice opening it turns into what I imagine someone who’s 1980s hair style, fur coat, chain smokes and stubs out her cigarette then heads in to a sushi restaurant and eats loads of sushi rolls. It’s overwhelmingly seaweed fish smell. With a little bit of smokiness. I’ll be trying the other two variants of this as I really was looking forward to a nice cold mango. Not smoked fish.

I hate it. It smells so gross. I can’t describe it. I love all things mint but this is a huge miss. Another reviewer said it smells like gross fish and I couldn’t agree more. She nailed it. It smells like open air fish market where the fish are all really fresh, none of the heavy dead fish smell you would get in a REAL open air fish market lol. Just straight up fresh fish on a cold day. It’s like if Roblox berry ave had a fish market. lol